Riders on the subway in New York City might have noticed a new addition to the transit system: a robot named K5. K5 is a crime-fighting machine that is supposed to make the subway safer and more secure. But is it really a good idea to have a robot watching over us?
The crime-fighting robot by the numbers
Credit: Knightscope
Credit: Knightscope
MORE: THE NEXT GENERATION OF TESLA’S HUMANOID ROBOT MAKES ITS DEBUT
The robot is part of a pilot program
K5 is part of a pilot program by the NYPD to deploy artificial intelligence (AI) robots in the subway system. The NYPD is reportedly renting K5 for $9 an hour from a company called Knightscope, which claims that its robots can reduce crime. The NYPD says that K5 can act as a physical deterrent to crime, as well as on-the-ground eyes to record those who commit crimes for future prosecution.
We reached out to Knightscope for a comment on this story, and this is what they tell us,
With so many crime fighting wins accumulated across the United States to date, Knightscope is honored to continue its work with public safety clients like NYPD helping to protect the places people live, work, study and visit.
Credit: Knightscope
MORE: HOW THIS ROBOT HELPS PROTECT AND CONNECT YOUR HOME
What are the benefits of the crime-fighting robot?
The NYPD argues that K5 can help them save money and resources, as they face staffing shortages and budget cuts. They say that K5 can patrol the subway 24/7, without needing breaks or vacations, and provide real-time data and alerts to the police. They also say that K5 can enhance public safety and trust, by providing a friendly and helpful presence in the subway.
Credit: Knightscope
Reaction to the robot
Some subway riders agree that K5 can make them feel safer and more comfortable. They say that K5 can deter potential criminals, such as pickpockets, vandals, or harassers, and provide a sense of security and protection. They also say that K5 can be fun and entertaining, as they can interact with it and take selfies with it.
Credit: Knightscope
MORE: THIS ROBOT PUPS GAS FOR YOU
What are the concerns about the robot?
However, not everyone is convinced that K5 is a good idea. Privacy advocates say that K5 is a state-sanctioned surveillance device that violates our constitutional rights. They say that K5 can collect and store massive amounts of personal data, such as faces, voices, locations, and behaviors, without our consent or knowledge. They also say that K5 can pose a threat to civil liberties and human dignity by creating a chilling effect on free speech and expression and by discriminating against certain groups or individuals based on biased algorithms.
Credit: Knightscope
Kurt’s key takeaways
As someone who rides the subway, I’m not feeling any safer with this robot around that I’ve noticed most people ignore altogether. I wonder how K5 can actually prevent or stop crimes when it can’t use force or arrest anyone. I also worry about how K5 can affect the privacy and autonomy of subway riders. I don’t think that K5 is a solution to the complex and systemic problems that plague the subway system.
What do you think of K5? Would you feel safer or more watched with this robot around? Let us know in the comments below.
FOR MORE OF MY SECURITY ALERTS, SUBSCRIBE TO MY FREE CYBERGUY REPORT NEWSLETTER HERE
Answers to the most asked CyberGuy questions: